Chapter 4
Cyclotomic fields
4.1. Dirichlet -functions
In this section, we summarize, largely without proof, various results regarding -functions of Dirichlet characters.
Definition 4.1.1. §
A multiplicative function is called a Dirichlet character if it is periodic of some period and for if and only if . The integer is called the modulus of .
Example 4.1.2. §
There is a unique Dirichlet character which has value at every , and it is known as the trivial character.
Definition 4.1.3. §
- a.
-
The conductor of a Dirichlet character is the smallest positive integer dividing its modulus such that there exists a Dirichlet character of modulus with for all with .
- b.
-
We say that a Dirichlet character is primitive if its conductor equals its modulus.
Definition 4.1.4. §
We say that a Dirichlet character is even (resp., odd) if (resp., .)
Every character gives rise to a Dirichlet character of modulus with for with . The resulting character has conductor , where is minimal such that factors through .
Definition 4.1.5. §
Let , and suppose that the induced Dirichlet character has conductor . The primitive Dirichlet character attached to is the primitive Dirichlet character of conductor that satisfies for , , where is any integer with and .
Let be an abelian field, and let be such that . The cyclotomic character then allows us to identify with a quotient of .
Notation 4.1.6. §
The set of primitive Dirichlet characters of consists of the primitive characters of conductor dividing attached to characters of that factor through .
Remark 4.1.7. §
A Dirichlet character is even if and only if the associated character on is even.
To any Dirichlet character, we can attach an -series.
Definition 4.1.8. §
Let be a Dirichlet character. The Dirichlet -series attached to is the complex-valued function on with defined by
Example 4.1.9. §
For , one has , the Riemann -function.
We note that Dirichlet -series have Euler product expansions.
Proposition 4.1.10. §
One has
for all with .
Theorem 4.1.11. §
The -series has a meromorphic continuation to all of that is analytic if , while is holomorphic aside from a simple pole at with residue .
Definition 4.1.12. §
The Dirichlet -function of a Dirichlet character is the meromorphic continuation of the -series to .
Definition 4.1.13. §
The -function is the unique meromorphic function on that satisfies
for all with and
for all for which it is defined.
Remark 4.1.14. §
The -function has poles, which are all simple, at exactly the nonpositive integers. It also satisfies for any positive integer .
Definition 4.1.15. §
The Gauss sum attached to a Dirichlet character of modulus is the value
Definition 4.1.16. §
For a Dirichlet character , we let denote its complex conjugate, which satisfies for all .
We mention a couple of basic lemmas regarding Gauss sums that will be of use.
Lemma 4.1.17. §
Let be a primitive Dirichlet character. Then we have
for all .
Proof.
If , then setting and , we have
and
for all . If , then
which gives the desired equality upon reordering the sum. □
Lemma 4.1.18. §
For a primitive Dirichlet character , we have
Proof.
Note that . We then have
and by Lemma 4.1.17, this equals
The latter sum of exponentials is zero unless , in which case it is . Hence,
□
Definition 4.1.19. §
For a primitive Dirichlet character , we set
Theorem 4.1.20. §
Let be a primitive Dirichlet character. Then the -functions of and satisfy the functional equation
for all .
We give the relationship between Dirichlet -functions and the Dedekind zeta function of an abelian field.
Proposition 4.1.21. §
Let be an abelian field. Then
Proof.
It suffices to check this on with by uniqueness of the meromorphic continuations. In turn, it suffices to check that for each prime , we have
| (4.1.1) |
As is Galois, we have , where is the common residue degree of the primes over in , so the lefthand side is just , where . Note that if is ramified in the fixed field of the kernel of . Thus, the product reduces to , where is the maximal subextension of that is unramified at . Viewing as a Galois character, is the value of on the Frobenius at , which is a generator of a cyclic subgroup of order in . Since , there are characters such that for a fixed primitive th root of unity and given integer with . The righthand side of (4.1.1) is then simply
as required. □
Corollary 4.1.22. §
Let be a Dirichlet character with associated primitive character nontrivial. Then .
Proof.
Since has a simple pole at , as does , for the trivial character of conductor , while is analytic for , this is a direct result of Proposition 4.1.21. □
4.2. Bernoulli numbers
Definition 4.2.1. §
For , the th Bernoulli number is the value of the th derivative of at .
In other words, is the rational number appearing in the Taylor expansion
Example 4.2.2. §
We have
so , , and after inverting the series.
Remark 4.2.3. §
Note that
so
is an even function, and therefore we have for all odd .
We shall require generalizations of these numbers attached to Dirichlet characters.
Definition 4.2.4. §
Let be a primitive Dirichlet character, and let be any multiple of . Then the generalized Bernoulli number is the algebraic number appearing in the series expansions
Remark 4.2.5. §
The independence from in the definition of is easily seen to boil down to the fact that
taking and .
Remark 4.2.6. §
We have for all , but .
Remark 4.2.7. §
We have that for , aside from .
We also have Bernoulli polynomials.
Definition 4.2.8. §
The th Bernoulli polynomial is the polynomial appearing in the series expansion
Example 4.2.9. §
We have and .
Lemma 4.2.10. §
Let be a primitive Dirichlet character, and let be a multiple of . We have
for .
Proof.
We have
□
Corollary 4.2.11. §
Let be a primitive, nontrivial Dirichlet character of conductor dividing . Then we have
Proof.
Since , the result follows from Lemma 4.2.10 and the fact that the sum over all for is zero, since is nontrivial. □
Definition 4.2.12. §
A value of at is known as an -value, or as a special value of the -function .
The following proposition gives a relationship between -values and generalized Bernoulli numbers.
Proposition 4.2.13. §
Let be a primitive Dirichlet character. Then we have
for all positive integers .
Proof.
Let with , and consider the complex function
For , set
where the path consists of the horizontal infinite path along the real axis to , followed by a counterclockwise traversal around the circle of radius , followed by the horizontal infinite path from along the positive real axis. Here, , where we take the branch of the logarithm given by the positive real axis. Then
If , the second term vanishes in the limit, and this simplifies to
where we set . The latter function can be meromorphically continued to all of and is again analytic away from . We therefore have
for all .
For , we obtain
by Cauchy’s integral formula. We have
so we obtain
Finally, setting , we need only note that
□
Theorem 4.2.14. §
Let be a nontrivial primitive Dirichlet character. We have
Proof.
If is odd, then the functional equation and the fact that imply that
Now let be even, and set . By Lemma 4.1.17, we then have
By Lemma 4.1.18 (and Lemma 4.1.17), we have that , and the evenness of plus the fact that the sum is taken over all mod tell us that we may replace with
□
Combining the analytic class number formula with Proposition 4.1.21 and Theorem 4.1.11, we obtain the following, which we will at times also refer to as the analytic class number formula.
Corollary 4.2.15. §
Let be an abelian field. Then we have
We note the following.
Lemma 4.2.16. §
Let be a CM field. Set . Then and
Proof.
Let be the generator of . For , we have under any complex embedding of , so . Consider the commutative diagram
Diagram description: Units and roots of unity in a CM field
The structural squares and triangles displayed here commute.
Objects, listed by row and column:
- Row 1, from left to right: column 2: 1; column 3: 1; column 4: 1.
- Row 2, from left to right: column 1: 1; column 2: left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket; column 3: mu (F); column 4: mu (F) superscript (2); column 5: 1.
- Row 3, from left to right: column 1: 1; column 2: E subscript (F) superscript (plus); column 3: E subscript (F); column 4: mu (F).
- Row 4, from left to right: column 1: 1; column 2: E subscript (F) superscript (plus) / left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket; column 3: E subscript (F) / mu (F); column 4: mu (F) / mu (F) superscript (2).
- Row 5, from left to right: column 2: 1; column 3: 1; column 4: 1.
Arrows and lines:
- An arrow from 1 (row 1, column 2) to left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket, without a label.
- An arrow from 1 (row 1, column 3) to mu (F) (row 2, column 3), without a label.
- An arrow from 1 (row 1, column 4) to mu (F) superscript (2), without a label.
- An arrow from 1 (row 2, column 1) to left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket, without a label.
- An arrow from left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket to mu (F) (row 2, column 3), without a label.
- An arrow from left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket to E subscript (F) superscript (plus), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) (row 2, column 3) to mu (F) superscript (2), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) (row 2, column 3) to E subscript (F), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) superscript (2) to 1 (row 2, column 5), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) superscript (2) to mu (F) (row 3, column 4), without a label.
- An arrow from 1 (row 3, column 1) to E subscript (F) superscript (plus), without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) superscript (plus) to E subscript (F), without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) superscript (plus) to E subscript (F) superscript (plus) / left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket, without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) to mu (F) (row 3, column 4), labelled 1 minus tau.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) to E subscript (F) / mu (F), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) (row 3, column 4) to mu (F) / mu (F) superscript (2), without a label.
- An arrow from 1 (row 4, column 1) to E subscript (F) superscript (plus) / left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket, without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) superscript (plus) / left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket to E subscript (F) / mu (F), without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) superscript (plus) / left angle bracket minus 1 right angle bracket to 1 (row 5, column 2), without a label.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) / mu (F) to mu (F) / mu (F) superscript (2), labelled 1 minus tau.
- An arrow from E subscript (F) / mu (F) to 1 (row 5, column 3), without a label.
- An arrow from mu (F) / mu (F) superscript (2) to 1 (row 5, column 4), without a label.
The snake lemma tells us that the cokernels of the two maps are isomorphic. The lower two rows yield
and the result follows. □
We remark that for cyclotomic fields, is computable.
Lemma 4.2.17. §
Let for some with . Then
Proof.
Let be the generator of . Note that
by the proof of Lemma 4.2.16. If is not a prime power, then is a unit, and , which generates . Thus in this case. Conversely, if generates for some , we would have . If were a power of a prime , then would generate the unique prime over in . Since this prime is ramified in , its generator cannot lie in . This forces to be if is a prime power. □
Notation 4.2.18. §
For a CM field , we set .
Lemma 4.2.19. §
Let be a CM field. Then
Proof.
Let
Suppose that satisfy
Then
which has index in , so Lemma 1.2.9 tells us that
On the other hand, note that each in Definition 1.2.4 is for but for , so
as desired. □
Corollary 4.2.15 implies the following.
Theorem 4.2.20. §
Suppose that is a CM abelian field. Then
Proof.
Let be an arbitrary abelian field. We remark that for , the quantity is the conductor of the corresponding character . Therefore, the conductor-discriminant formula tells us that
| (4.2.1) |
Moreover, a comparison of the functional equations of the Dirichlet -functions and the Artin -functions yields that
so
| (4.2.2) |
Taking the quotient of the analytic class number formula for by that for and applying Theorem 4.2.14, we obtain
| (4.2.3) |
Applying (4.2.1) and (4.2.2) for and , we see that
and Lemma 4.2.19 tells us that
since . Equation (4.2.3) is then immediately reduced to the desired form.
On the other hand, the analytic class number formula for and Theorem 4.2.14 give
Applying (4.2.1) and (4.2.2) and noting that replacing by in the resulting sum makes no difference in the result, we obtain the formula for . □
4.3. Cyclotomic units
The product appearing in the formula for in Theorem 4.2.20 may appear itself something like a regulator. This is essentially the case.
Definition 4.3.1. §
If is an abelian field contained in for , we let and define the group of cyclotomic -units of to be the subgroup
of , where is a primitive th root of unity. The group of cyclotomic units of is then defined as the intersection .
Remark 4.3.2. §
The definition of is independent of the multiple of the conductor of .
We have the following result of Hasse, which is due to Kummer in the case of for a prime .
Theorem 4.3.3 (Hasse). §
Let for an odd prime and . Then we have
Proof.
The set
forms an independent set of generators of . Let us let denote the regulator of the latter set. Then is the absolute value of the determinant of the matrix with rows and columns indexed by the integers prime to with with entries in the row and column corresponding to given by , where . Now
Proposition 1.5.18 applied to the group yields
As has conductor dividing and
for and , we have
By Theorem 4.2.20, it then follows that . On the other hand, we have by Lemma 1.2.9. □
Sinnott proved the following more general result, the proof of which we omit.
Theorem 4.3.4 (Sinnott). §
Let for with . Then we have
where
for the number of distinct primes dividing .
A standard choice of primitive th roots of unity for , viewing as a subset of , is to take for . This choice has the advantage that for dividing . Let us make such a choice. We first remark that the elements for divisible by two distinct primes are in fact units.
Lemma 4.3.5. §
If is divisible by two distinct primes, then .
Proof.
For a positive integer , let denote the th cyclotomic polynomial. We have
so it suffices to show that . We have
Plugging in , we obtain
Note for any power of a prime . Expressing as a product of powers of distinct primes , we then also have
Since each is an integer, it follows that , as desired. □
Next, we note the compatibility of the elements under norms.
Lemma 4.3.6. §
For and a prime , we have
Proof.
Note that
If divides , then the left-hand side runs over the conjugates of under , so the product equals the norm.
If does not divide , then let with . We then have , so the conjugates of have the form with . As and , moving the term from the product to the other side, we have
□
4.4. Reflection theorems
We now refine Theorem 1.4.15 by working with eigenspaces. Start with a totally real field . Let
be a character with finite image. Any embedding of in fixes an element that is the restriction of complex conjugation in , since is taken to a subfield of under the embedding. All such complex conjugations in arise in this way, and they form distinct conjugacy classes in for the real embeddings of in . In , these complex conjugations restrict to exactly distinct elements, with the elements of the same class restricting to the same element.
Definition 4.4.1. §
We say that a character of a totally real field is totally even if is trivial on all complex conjugations and totally odd if is nontrivial on all complex conjugations. If , we say more simply that is even or odd in the respective cases.
We let denote the extension of that is the fixed field of the kernel of , which will itself be totally real if is totally even and CM if is totally odd. If , these are the only cases.
We now suppose that has order prime to a given odd prime . We fix an embedding , which allows us to view as a character with values in , and hence in .
One key character of interest to us is the Teichmüller character
which has image contained in and is defined by the equality
for any and . Note that the Teichmüller character is a totally odd character on .
Theorem 4.4.2 (Leopoldt’s Spiegelungsatz). §
Let be a totally real field, and let be a totally odd character of finite order prime to . Let be an abelian extension of of degree prime to that contains . Then we have
where is unless and the extension is unramified, in which case it is .
Proof.
Let . Let be the ring generated over by the character values of . Let denote the residue field of , and let denote the residue field of , the ring of values of , for any . As is unramified over , we have .
For a finite -module , we let . We remark that Lemma 2.8.7 implies that
Note also that we have
so
| (4.4.1) |
Since and since unless , in which case , equation (4.4.1) tells us that the desired inequalities are equivalent to
where we have set to shorten notation.
Note that we have the following isomorphisms of groups
the first step following from the freeness of over and the second from the adjointness of and . Moreover, Lemma 2.8.7 implies that
for any . Recalling Lemma 1.4.6, we then have an exact sequence
where is the set of elements of that have th roots that generate unramified extensions of . Since is a one-dimensional -vector space, we have
which as the -dual of a -vector space has dimension equal to .
In the case that , we then have that
since the -power roots of unity in have trivial -eigenspace unless , which happens if and only if , as takes its values in . On the other hand, if we take , then we have
finishing the proof. □
In the special case that and , we remark that , as is ramified at the unique prime over . Moreover, we have the following.
Lemma 4.4.3. §
Let be an even integer. Then
Corollary 4.4.4. §
For any even integer , we have
Corollary 4.4.5. §
We have .
4.5. Stickelberger theory
Let us fix an integer and a primitive th root of unity throughout this section.
Definition 4.5.1. §
Let , and let .
- a.
-
For with , let be such that . The Stickelberger element is the element of given by
- b.
-
The Stickelberger ideal of is the ideal of .
Lemma 4.5.2. §
Let denote the ideal of generated by elements of the form for with . Then .
Proof.
For , we have and . Suppose that . Let us use to denote the fractional part of . We note
Since , we have for all prime to , and hence .
Now take with . Writing this out, we have
which implies that
But note that , so . We then have
finishing the proof. □
In the following definition and lemmas, we use to denote the finite field trace down to a prime field.
Definition 4.5.3. §
Let be a power of a prime and be a character, which we extend to a function by . The Gauss sum attached to is
Lemma 4.5.4. §
Let be a power of a prime prime to . Let be a character, so .
- a.
-
For with , we have .
- b.
-
Let be relatively prime to , and let be the unique lift of . Then
- c.
-
In particular, we have .
Proof.
For the first statement, we compute
For nontrivial , the Gauss sum is nonzero by the following lemma. For the trivial character, by additive character orthogonality. On the other hand, we have as fixes . Thus, we see that
proving the second statement. For the third, take . □
Lemma 4.5.5. §
Let be a power of a prime and be a nontrivial character. Then
Proof.
Let be the additive character . It is nontrivial since the trace pairing is nondegenerate, so maps onto . We have
The term of the sum contributes , since each in that case. For , it contributes as
by character orthogonality for the additive group of . Putting these together, we have
where the middle equality follows from character orthogonality for , since is nontrivial. □
We state Stickelberger’s theorem for . A similar result holds for abelian fields in general.
Theorem 4.5.6 (Stickelberger). §
Let , and set . Then the Stickelberger ideal of annihilates the class group: .
Proof.
For , the class group of is trivial. Suppose that , and fix . By the Čebotarev density theorem applied to the conjugacy class of in , we may choose a prime ideal of representing above a rational prime that splits completely in . Note that , and let be a primitive root modulo . Let denote the character with . There is a unique prime of lying above , and . We use to denote the additive valuation attached to . For prime to , and the unique lift of , we set
By Lemma 4.5.5, we have that , so , and by Lemma 4.5.4, we have in the smaller field that
In other words, we have the factorization
so
annihilates the class of .
Now take given by . Then since every prime over is totally ramified in , we have that is in the inertia group of all such primes. Note that
for all . Using the action of on , we calculate
This forces and therefore modulo , since both sides of the latter congruence lie in . In other words, we have
On the other hand, there exists some prime to such that
We therefore have that
forcing
It follows that
Now suppose is such that . We then have
By Lemmas 4.5.2 and 4.5.4, we have . Therefore, the identity
actually holds, and so we see that annihilates . So, annihilates , and we are done. □
This has an interesting application for the field .
Theorem 4.5.7 (Herbrand). §
Let be an odd prime, and set . Let be an odd integer, and suppose that . Then . Moreover, we have .
Proof.
By Stickelberger’s theorem, we have that . In particular, we have that annihilates , where is the idempotent attached to . Note that for prime to , we have
where we have applied Corollary 4.2.11 in the last step. It follows that annihilates for all prime to . Choosing to be a primitive root modulo , we have that , so if is nontrivial, then must be divisible by . For , we note that
so we get that annihilates , hence the result. □
As with the plus part, the minus part of the class number of a cyclotomic field of prime power roots of unity can be interpreted as an index, as in the following result of Iwasawa.
Theorem 4.5.8 (Iwasawa). §
Let for a prime and . Then
Proof.
We may suppose that . For the complex conjugation , we have , so the projection of to is
The -module generated by in is and contains .
For any prime to , we have
so is cyclic, generated by the class of . Let . We have , so . On the other hand, the coefficient of in is , so the class of has order a multiple of , which is therefore .
Now, for any odd character , we have for the idempotent of in , so . Multiplication by on the -line therefore has eigenvalue . It follows that
the last step by Theorem 4.2.20. □
Consider the following modification of the Stickelberger ideal of :
where
for a positive divisor of . (Note that .) The proof of Stickelberger’s theorem extends to show that annihilates . Sinnott proved the following.
Theorem 4.5.9 (Sinnott). §
Let for a positive integer . Then
where
for the number of distinct primes dividing .